Wow, Since When Are Gamers So Protective Of Women?
When gamers heard that Lara Croft might face rape situations in the upcoming Tomb Raider reboot, the fans went and freakin' exploded.
Although Crystal Dynamics cleared things up quite nicely, the wounds suffered from that little PR flap won't heal easily, as some still appear miffed. I found the whole thing awfully interesting because it was, in a way, quite sentimental and traditional.
I think it went beyond the fact that a video game icon might be facing a personally nightmarish event. I think it was a bunch of people genuinely pissed off that a female character - fictitious though she may be - was going to be in a very intimate sort of horrible danger, and we'd be watching and to some extent controlling her. And that got me thinking- Since when is this particular community so hell-bent on protecting females? That doesn't fall in line with what was predicted.
Heck, we've bashed them across the ring in just about every fighter ever created, and we've constantly turned them into sex objects in countless other games. Just how protective can this group be, after being exposed to such careless disregard for a lady's safety? ...hmm, perhaps it could be that we still remember the "damsel in distress" scenarios from our youth, and rescuing Princess Peach, while all cute and simple, might have instilled in us the "hero gene." Maybe the gaming culture is more conservative and traditional than the rest of the world. Maybe they're actually more protective of those virtual incarnations of females.
One of the reasons the feminists and other anti-game activists have hated how women have been portrayed - subject to all sorts of violence and constantly objectified - in games is obvious: They think this indoctrinated us. They thought it would create legions of neanderthal Type-A men who have zero respect for women. Ah, but it seems quite the contrary in my experience. Most people I know who grew up as gamers have an old-fashioned respect for women that almost borders on deference, and that's more than I can say for other people I knew who didn't grow up with games. I once found that odd; now it's a feather in our caps.
Were the haters just plain wrong? From the first moment we rescued the princess, were we already experiencing the subtle, even subconscious, stirrings of good old-fashioned female respect? And even when we are slamming into the top-heavy chicks in DoA, maybe we're not necessarily absorbing that and interpreting it...i.e., we're not gonna try the same thing in real life. In fact, it really might be having the opposite effect. It's not just that Lara is an icon; it's that she's a woman and in all honesty, I really think gamers are far more protective of women (no, really) than any of the politicians wanted to believe.
So there.
Tags: lara croft, tomb raider, tomb raider reboot, gaming culture, gamers
6/29/2012 10:34:06 PM Ben Dutka
Put this on your webpage or blog:
Email this to a friend
Follow PSX Extreme on Twitter
Comments (30 posts)
Doppel
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 11:39:45 AM
Clamedeus
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 5:14:36 PM
PharaohJR
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 5:27:21 PM
WorldEndsWithMe
Friday, June 29, 2012 @ 11:14:45 PM
oldmike
Monday, July 02, 2012 @ 3:04:48 PM
WorldEndsWithMe
Friday, June 29, 2012 @ 11:13:42 PM
Reply
I guess as far as action and fighters go, if it's me or them then I'd rather it be them. If a chick is gonna put me on ice then I gotta do what I gotta do. (Though I also often prefer to play as the woman.) I think that's different from some icky creepy men taking advantage of a stranded girl who does not yet have badass skills. Leave that to the porn industry.
Looking Glass
Friday, June 29, 2012 @ 11:46:06 PM
Reply
It seems that a lot of games over the years have been disrespectful to women in one way or another such as sexual objectification to one degree or another or portraying them (to one degree or another) as damsels in distress who are ineffectual, unable to really take care of themselves, and need to be rescued. And I realize that I'm stating the obvious but damsel in distress scenarios are disrespectful to women because they are detrimental to the idea of female strength.
To the best of my knowledge uproars like the one over the Lara Croft thing don't happen as often as video games being disrespectful to women in some way. Therefore it seems reasonable that the primary motivator is Lara Crofts icon status. If Lara were completely removed from the equation and replaced by some completely new female character that no one's heard of before would the reaction have been the same? I have my doubts.
It's probably also worth noting that while being protective of women and being respectful toward them might sometimes go hand in hand the two are by no means one and the same. For example a man could be protective of a woman because he believes, whether consciously or unconsciously, that she is incapable of taking care of herself. I've actually encountered this kind of attitude in entertainment media before.
Lawless SXE
Friday, June 29, 2012 @ 11:55:01 PM
Reply
Perhaps it's just that some people are brought up with a sense of Romanticism, something that the "damsel in distress" only serves to strengthen. I doubt it's exclusive to gamers, just as I doubt that those leaping to the defence of Lara in this situation (from a journalistic standpoint) are the norm. Those that are for the situation are more likely to keep their fingers stilled and mouths shut because they know the shellacking that they'll cop if they do write up an article titled "Why The Rape of Lara Croft Is A Good Thing", no matter how concise and powerful the arguments put forth in it are.
I suppose it ties into this apparent movement of games journalists attacking the objectification of women. What about the response to Hitman Sexy Nuns trailer. If I remember correctly, there was something of a murmur of dissatisfaction when Lollipop Chainsaw first came into the spotlight. I hope that the crying out against such things are a sign of a growing maturity that doesn't necessarily want to see women as sex objects. We didn't love Nariko because she was a busty, scantily-clad damsel (she kinda was, but her character model still left a lot to the imagination), just as we didn't love Elena Fisher for the very same reason. Instead, they were relatively realistic people.
I'd keep going, but I'm getting off track.
Peace.
Lawless SXE
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 12:01:10 AM
Ludicrous_Liam
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 5:35:39 AM
Underdog15
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 9:35:19 AM
WorldEndsWithMe
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 1:04:11 AM
Reply
Underdog15
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 9:36:35 AM
Temjin001
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 1:11:09 AM
Reply
In terms of women in fighters I think that's pretty different because the female is empowered equally to the male and the fights are staged tournaments. I don't see it so much as a situation where women are being preyed on and victimized or overpowered by a more POWERFUL male. Ironically, speaking of fighters. Fighters like SF. The first mainstream game related encounter I can remember is the anime SF2 movie with a scene between Chun Li and Vega (this movie was included on a PS2 released game as well). I don't really remember any rape outcry on behalf of Chun Li (maybe there was?). Anyway, until we have Tomb Raider games with Lara running helplessly in terror holding her clothes on while escaping vile men predators (should'nt males be offended that we' being portrayed as lowly animals?) I'm not too worried about this stuff, just because it doesnt seem anything out of the ordinary from like rated films or other media.
Anyway, I drew up tribute art to many of my all time favorite gaming experiences. Lara is included ;) The first TR on PSX absorbed me like few games ever had. Back then fully explorable 3D environments we a rare find.
Anyway, I'm sure there's more than one fan favorite in here. FF was represented with Sabin. I loved him because he was like a Street Fighter character in a FF ;) That and SNES FF3 was the first FF I played through and finished and got absorbed in.
http://david-mason.deviantart.com/#/d54yzfx
Last edited by Temjin001 on 6/30/2012 1:12:29 AM
WorldEndsWithMe
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 10:09:20 AM
Temjin001
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 6:38:04 PM
JonnyR
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 5:04:08 AM
Reply
In my mind thats what they were going for and it would have been acceptable (its already acceptable in tv, films and books)to place a female character in serious real world situations, if it goes towards the development of character. is it impossible to comprehend a character who has ALWAYS been a sex symbol would never find herself in this kind of situation?
Is allowing this kind of subject matter into a game going to increase rape in society? is removing it from the game and pretending that rape doesnt exist going to reduce the occurence of rape in the real world? NO.
What will happen is the gaming industry will cower and it will be a few years before anyone dares to try anything so risque again. so the image everyone else has of the games industry is left to be made by the guys who see nothing wrong with sexy gun toting nuns being slaughtered.
Coffeya
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 7:10:39 AM
Reply
___________
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 8:07:48 AM
Reply
;)
the reaction had nothing to do with lara being a women though, the reaction was because of hey this is not lara.
people are so use to her kicking a$$, taking names while dodging falling flaming beams across buildings on fire!
which is really stupid, the whole point of the game is to show how lara became that so of course shes going to be a stereotypical girl.
Excelsior1
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 9:00:06 AM
Reply
daus26
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 4:08:06 PM
Reply
Now, if the guy's comment was really intended like how the gamers perceived, I think it would have to do more with morals, especially in gaming, more so than being over protective with women. Anything having to do with "raping" will generate a lot of discussions. It's nothing new.
PharaohJR
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 5:51:18 PM
Reply
as said in the last post concerning this topic i believe forcing & abusing a female for whatever reasons is a weak being. if i have the funds to purchase TR the fact this scenrio is in the game wont alter me from playing. its no different from authors who write books touch on subject from their aspect or movie directors.
i do believe if u can purchase cds edited same with movies it should be same with games. give the option that was offered in COD on terrorist stage.
saintaqua
Saturday, June 30, 2012 @ 9:12:08 PM
Reply
That said, I will have to see that scene before I can say if it's right or wrong in a game...but sadly Tomb Raider is pretty low on my list of games I want to play.
locoforte
Sunday, July 01, 2012 @ 12:40:14 PM
Reply
Besides, how many hookers have we collectively beaten up in GTA games over the years?

Tomb Raider









Clamedeus
Reply
Friday, June 29, 2012 @ 10:59:10 PM
But I guess it depends on how it's implemented in a game, I don't really get worked up on games that have things like that in a game, but if I have the chance to retaliate in the game, you bet I will.