User Reviews: Prototype 2 PS3 User Review

Members Login: Register | Why sign up? | Forgot Password?

Prototype 2 User Review

More Game Info (Print This Article)













Replay Value:



Overall Rating:       8.5



Online Gameplay:

Not Rated

Number Of Players:




When Radical Entertainment released Prototype, it was regarded by many as a doppleganger to Sony's inFamous developed by Suckerpunch, and it generated quite a following who even regarded it as the better game. Having played and beaten both, I found the comparison rather misplaced, because although both titles were super hero/villian open-world games taking place in renditions of catastrophe stricken NYCs, inFamous was a focused, albeit frenetic, over-the-shoulder shooter with climbing/platforming emphasis and an engrossing story with characters you cared about, while Prototype was a hack'n slash fest having vehicular combat and stealth gameplay, and emphasis on chaotic and heart-racing action with more akin to Hulk:Ultimate Destruction and Crackdown. Still, if a comparison had to be made, visually, and presentation-wise and regarding story, it was no contest. Prototype, while packing solid gameplay mechanics and plenty of adrenaline, didn't hold a candle to inFamous.

Almost 3 years later, Radical Entertainment has released the 2nd "Prototype", and after a ravenous week's worth of play time, and nailing the platinum, I can confidently say Radical Entertainment outdid themselves in many ways.

The visual quality in P2 is closer to inFamous than it is to the first Prototype, which had PS2'ish texture quality and detail. P2's character models are far improved, building windows and puddles show dynamic reflections (something not even done in inFamous nor even Crysis 2), dynamic shadows, physics and weather effects are convincingly rendered, and the city is looking far less generic than it did in the first time around, all the while retaining the blistering speed, over-the-top action free of screen-tear of slow-down, and maintaining the swarms and droves of on screen characters and objects found in the prequel. The canned animations and qte's are brutally visceral, cinematically framed, and diverse having different permutations depending on your equipped powers and the enemy type or vehicle of your target. While Prototype 2 visually is not on par with the open world games like Just Cause 2, Red Dead Redemption, LA Noire, or the Assassin's Creed titles, the level of action, speed, and sheer number of on screen assets puts it in a class of it's own. A very arcady, and menacing class of it's own.

The story, however, once again, seemed like a missed opportunity. Like the first, it contains 9/11 anachronisms/parallels, and references to military/industrial complex, private military corporations like Black Water (known in the game as "Black Watch") and pharmaceutical ones, government cover ups, secret organizations running the world, shape-shifters, the occult, and generally to all things having to do with conspiracies (warning:if you're allergic to that kind of stuff, you might not like this game just for that). Yet, the character interactions and events are mostly disjointed, and hurried, feeling mostly just like side-missions. And while the phenomenon of shape-shifting pose genuinely deep questions about sentience, identity and morality, it doesn't really go anywhere with it, which is unfortunate. The ending was entirely predictable and a bit of cop-out.

And, while the voice acting is clearly as professional as inFamous's, the script lines, especially that of the main character's, were, more often than not, hastily written, filled with heavy handed, unconvincing, awkward cursing, which was a real waste of the voice-acting talent. Still, the story was interesting enough to punctuate the action and gameplay...and still was head and shoulders above that which is found in something like Just Cause 2. The CGI was expertly produced showing particularly realist facial expressions, with subtle use of color, powerful imagery, and the music really was quite stirring, mimicking the tracks of Matrix and Christopher's Nolans works complete with the death horns.

I was particularly impressed by the sound-effects. One time, I slammed a body to the ground, which made a clanging thawwng noise when the head happened to hit some debris of a pipe. And the chatter, conversations, spontaneous behavior and reactions of the bystanders and passerby-ers were impressive. One time I happened to land on a rooftop where a bystander was attempting suicide by slowly tipping over backwards off a ledge. I ran in and grabbed him, just before he fell off. He began to plead to me to let him go and that we should work together to fight the bad guys. Lol! I'm glad he had a change of heart. I wanted to let him go w/o chucking him to his death, which would've defeated the purpose of saving him. Thankfully, I figured out by hitting down on the direction button, I let him go. I felt I should've got a trophy for my virtual act of simulated, compassionate good samaritanism, but whatever, it's little, surprising details like that which makes an open-world game feel that much more convincingly immersive and engrossing, which is the reward in it's own.

And alas, the gameplay. Here is where Prototype improved most crucially. While I said before that Prototype 1 wasn't much like inFamous, it seems Radical Entertainment took obvious cues from the reception that inFamous got. For example, the side missions are now structured more like inFamous's, where you pick up dead-drops, take out armed gangs, and underground lairs...but instead of just leaving you to comb the areas as you did with blast shards in inFamous, or just following your nose to some icon on the map, you have an alternate view of the map, under the menu option called "collectibles", which indicates the general location of such side missions or locales by using neary-by radio blips on the map, after you select the type of "collectible you wish to search for. This saves one a great deal of tedium from the search, while retaining some of the spontaneity and surprise. Collecting all the particular type of collectibles, such as dead drops, in a particular region will reward you with an upgrade such as to a power (like claws, blade, whipfist, tentacles, hammer fists) or an ability (like locomotion, health, regen, stealth, or to summon a beast pack to fight along your side etc) or weapon and vehicle use (such as rifle, rocket launcher, tank, helicopter, etc). Sometimes, there are side-missions that don't show up on a map, but show up on the on screen gps with a head, dna-helix or flexed muscle icon, which also shows up on top of the character when they come into your view. These will give you similar upgrades, or bonus ability upgrades, or exp bonuses, or sometimes they reveal the location of a terminal where you get to trigger side missions. Exp points attained add to your level, which also rewards you with an upgrade each time you level up. It caps off at level 23 (the total number of pairs of human chromosomes). This took me an initial playthrough on hard setting, and half a playthrough on easy to attain, and hence trigger the "all growed up" trophy.

The racing, obstacle courses, and challenges have now been moved to something else called RADNET, selectable from the in-game menu. Completing a set of events, grants you mutation rewards, unlocks videos, and completing all of the sets unlocks the Alex Mercer skin. These sets are unlocked on fix dates, obviously to keep you from trading your copy in, and each event has it's own online leadership board, where you can compare your performance and results with you friends. Though, the controls and camera are loose, and hit detection not pixel accurate, which sometimes is problematic when you want to grab a can instead of an enemy, or when you want to stealth grab an enemy instead of a table, they are reliable enough most of the time. I particularly enjoyed setting the best times in the obstacle courses, because running, jumping, dashing, and gliding makes traversing the world in Prototype 2 such a rush, which frankly is almost half the joy in these types of games.

The core gameplay of the main missions vary between escort missions, defending positions from enemy onslaughts, infiltrating bases with stealth, enemy search & chases, and boss fights. The powers at your disposal, as previously mentioned, are diverse and imaginative, yielding many creative and brutally visceral ways to take out your enemies, and figuring out the optimal combination of powers and abilities can make short work out of them. The stealth mechanics and rules have been streamlined from the first game making them quicker and less meandering affairs. Boss fights can vary between fighting one-on-one or many shapeshifters like yourself, and fighting gargantuam building-size colossi as you did in inFamous 2. They do not have scale or the visuals as they did in inFamous 2, but they have there own uniquely creative touches about their design and how to overcome them which actually make them more interesting.

After all is said and done, I must say, while Prototype 2 does not have the polish, scale, and presentation of the inFamous franchise, it still is an addictive game where Radical Entertainment exhibited a surprising level of attention to detail in just so many ways. Marred by forgivable blemishes, it still is a fun and addictive romp in action, highly recommended to both fans of the original Prototype as well as those waiting on inFamous 3 (which I hear is in the works).

This user review does not reflect the views of the PSX Extreme Staff.

User review by Shams

5/28/2012 4:08:15 PM

Put this on your webpage or blog:
Email this to a friend
Follow PSX Extreme on Twitter

Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on Google Share on MySpace Share on Delicious Share on Digg Share on Google Buzz Share via E-Mail Share via Tumblr Share via Posterous

New Comment System

Legacy Comment System (5 posts)

Friday, June 01, 2012 @ 2:13:26 PM

Nice review :) I might give this a shot, when it drops in price.

Agree with this comment 1 up, 0 down Disagree with this comment

Sunday, June 03, 2012 @ 10:13:45 AM

Thanks, Xenris. Looking forward to reading your's as well!

Agree with this comment 0 up, 0 down Disagree with this comment

Friday, June 01, 2012 @ 4:20:13 PM

I don't really like the open-ended mindlessness of Prototype; I much prefer the formulaic, structured quality of Infamous. Still, a really in-depth review Shams :)

Agree with this comment 0 up, 0 down Disagree with this comment

Friday, June 01, 2012 @ 9:52:09 PM

Thats what turned me off as well. I find when a game is too open, I just get bored. I like sandbox games on occasion but I'm more into structured things.

Agree with this comment 0 up, 0 down Disagree with this comment

Sunday, June 03, 2012 @ 10:19:23 AM

Thanks, Ludicrous Liam! Oh, yes, I still think inFamous is the better franchise, but Prototype has taken it's cues from SuckerPunch this time around. For example, the mission structure, and pacing is much more focused in the sequel adopting a mission structure similar to inFamous's, while pushing the previous side-mission/challenge events to something called RADNET. Also, the stealth mechanics/rules have been streamlined, so now the infiltration segments are less meandering. Overall, it's less loosy-goosy compared to the prequel, in terms of pacing of the story and mission structure.

Agree with this comment 0 up, 0 down Disagree with this comment

Leave a Comment

Please login or register to leave a comment.

Our Poll

How often do you visit the site?
Once a day
Several times a day
Every few days
Once a week
This is my first visit
I've never been here, even now I am not here

Previous Poll Results