User Reviews: Red Dead Redemption PS3 User Review

Members Login: Register | Why sign up? | Forgot Password?

Red Dead Redemption User Review

More Game Info (Print This Article)













Replay Value:



Overall Rating:       9.8



Online Gameplay:

Not Rated

Number Of Players:

1 (1-16 Online)



     John Marston is a simple man - he wants only to live peacefully with his wife and son on his ranch.  John Marston is a complicated man - a former outlaw tasked with bringing down his former friends by the U.S. government in order to ensure his future and family remain safe.  This dichotomy represents the crux of the moral argument that is Red Dead Redemption.  Because here's the thing: This is less about the moral compass of John Marston than it is the player's. John is essentially a blank slate. You're given his backstory and an understanding that he's lived two wholly different lives thus far but it is the player's choice to see which side wins out in the end - if at all.

     This is Rockstar at their best.  Creating vast landscapes that suck you in and make you feel like you will always have the last word in anything happening around you.  Run, shoot, stab, or lasso your way from shack to farm to town to small city.  Become a bounty hunter and bring the wanted back, dead or alive.  Hunt any of the creatures you see roaming the wilds.  Tame wild horses and sell them, ride them, or race them for money. Go into town and get drunk, fight or even engage in a shoot out.  Intervene in domestic disputes or gamble your earnings away.  There is so much to do that you may forget about the larger missions which propel the narrative forward.  Speaking of narrative, this may be one of the strongest game scripts ever written.  This is a game told through the soul of Sam Peckinpah. Dirty characters dong dirty deeds.  Visceral, violent and raw but always the truth.  The world constantly changes around you.  Nothing is stagnant rather it constantly evolves, giving you a new experience every time you set out.

     Marston controls like a dream.  Running, shooting and taking cover are all a snap.  Riding horses makes you feel like a real cowboy.  The best way to describe the pleasure of playing Red Dead is weight.  Everything has a certain weight.  A repeater feels heavier than a pistol.  Your horse's hooves feel like they're digging into the earth as you gallop across the plains.  It's all so grounded.  Going uphill can be a chore, you feel the weight difference, the friction.  The dead-eye meter is an interesting concept, perhaps originating with Max Payne's bullet time but here it's perfectly executed.  Being able to stop time and disarm, de-hat or straight kill multiple enemies makes you truly feel like a gunslinger.

     The story can be completed in 20-30 hours with missions scattered throughout the game to teach you new game mechanics that help you fully appreciate the depth at play.  It all feels so natural and once you get the hang of everything you can do, you feel a real sense of accomplishment.  Alliances are made and broken.  People come and go an die at will throughout the story.  There's a true sense of gravity to the story and your actions seem to have a true consequence on the game world.  The final act throws one last delicious curve ball at the player, ending in a bloodbath and one of the most memorable and heart wrenching endings any game has ever had.  Ever.

     From a technical standpoint this game is rendered very well.  Riding across the desert with the sun setting behind distant mountains is a lasting image.  The detail of the period clothing down to the dirty and dusty nature of your hat or overcoat is impressive.  Bullets whizz by your head and ricochet off hard surfaces.  Your boots clacking off wood planks or crunching in the sand or snow are all so realistic to make you feel like you're actually in the wild wild west.  The expansive voice cast all give note perfect performances making this a complete technical package.

     Red Dead Redemption has the ability to suck your life away.  There's good reason to play through the main story a second time to maybe make some opposite moral choices.  There are also a few different trophies to unlock for making specific gameplay choices.  Hell, this crazy group of characters are worth spending more time with for no other reason than to do just that.  Multiplayer is a whole other animal and also what puts this game over the top as one of the best values we've ever seen.  There's a co-op mode that allows to take on missions with up to three other friends.  You have your normal menu of game modes but the reason to get excited here is free roam.  This is essentially the multiplayer lobby but it allows you access to the entire game world.  You can hook up with your friends and do whatever you want.  Kill each other, hunt, race, clear hideouts, raise hell in town, whatever you want. Genius.

     In the end, Red Dead Redemption is that game you expect to be great due to its pedigree but it still surprises you.  From the writing to the art direction. The voice cast to sound design.  Custom options to multiplayer.  Great games are the sum of their parts but when all of their parts are equally great, it becomes special.  Red Dead Redemption is all of these things and still it's more.  It's the most complete vision Rockstar has ever produced and is so good it wouldn't only make Peckinpah proud but jealous too.

This user review does not reflect the views of the PSX Extreme Staff.

User review by Gorilla Biscuit

6/9/2012 8:47:23 PM

Put this on your webpage or blog:
Email this to a friend
Follow PSX Extreme on Twitter

Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on Google Share on MySpace Share on Delicious Share on Digg Share on Google Buzz Share via E-Mail Share via Tumblr Share via Posterous

New Comment System

Legacy Comment System (0 posts)

There are no comments to display.

Leave a Comment

Please login or register to leave a comment.

Latest Updates

Shadow of the Colossus Review
10d, 7h, 59m ago (2 comments)

Strikers Edge Review
14d, 8h, 39m ago (19 comments)

Okami HD Review
15d, 6h, 31m ago (6 comments)

Ultimate Chicken Horse Review
19d, 1h, 25m ago (16 comments)

Black Mirror Review
34d, 13h, 27m ago (23 comments)

Our Poll

How often do you visit the site?
Once a day
Several times a day
Every few days
Once a week
This is my first visit
I've never been here, even now I am not here

Previous Poll Results